Schizophrenia or Divine Revelation? Understanding Joan of Arcs Mental Struggles
Well, let me tell ya, there’s been a lot of talk over the years about that gal Joan of Arc. Some folks say she was a saint, a real messenger of God, and others, well, they ain’t so sure about her being all holy. Some say she was just hearing voices, you know, like folks with a certain kind of sickness that messes with their mind. Now, I ain’t no expert or nothing, but I reckon there’s been a lot of confusion ’bout this Joan. Was she sent by God or was somethin’ else goin’ on with her? Let me tell ya, this whole thing’s a real mystery!
Joan, or Jeanne, like they called her back in the day, started hearin’ voices when she was just a young girl. They say she was ’round 12 or 13, somethin’ like that. And these voices, well, she said they was angels or saints talkin’ to her. Now, in them times, folks didn’t understand much about what we call mental health today. They didn’t have no fancy doctors, no mental health hospitals, nothin’ like that. So, when Joan was hearing voices, they thought it was either a miracle or something gone wrong in her head. Some folks even said she was just plain crazy, poor thing.
What Did She Hear?
She claimed them voices were Saint Michael, Saint Catherine, and Saint Margaret, all big names in the French Church. These voices told her to go and lead the French army to victory, to help ‘em win back their land. Now, can you imagine that? A young girl, no older than a teenager, tellin’ the soldiers what to do and bein’ so sure of herself? That’s powerful stuff, if you ask me. But the question still hangs in the air: was she really hearin’ the voices of saints, or was it somethin’ else? Could it be she had a sickness that made her think this way?
Was Joan of Arc Schizophrenic?
Some folks nowadays think that Joan might’ve had schizophrenia. Now, I don’t know much about that, but I heard folks sayin’ that schizophrenia can make a person hear voices and see things that ain’t really there. This condition, well, it’s real complicated, and back in Joan’s time, they didn’t even know what it was. They didn’t have no words for it, so when Joan started hearing them voices, maybe they just thought it was a sign from God. But looking back now, some doctors reckon that this poor girl might’ve been suffering from schizophrenia. It’s like her mind was playin’ tricks on her, but back then, they didn’t have no ways to understand it like we do now.
What Were The Signs?
Now, let’s take a look at some of the things that happened. Joan wasn’t just hearing voices, no ma’am. She had visions too, seein’ saints and angels. Folks sayin’ she was seeing things that no one else could see, and that might’ve made ‘em think she was just a bit touched in the head. But if you ask me, I reckon she believed every bit of it. She was so sure of what she was seein’ and hearin’ that she started marching around, telling the king what to do and even leading the army to battle. It’s like she had a fire in her that wouldn’t go out. Maybe it wasn’t just her mind playin’ tricks on her; maybe it was somethin’ deeper. But like I said before, we just don’t know for sure.
What Did The Doctors Say?
In more recent times, some doctors and scholars have looked back at Joan’s life and tried to figure out what was going on with her. Some folks say she might’ve had epilepsy too, not just schizophrenia. Epilepsy can cause people to have strange experiences, like seeing things or hearing voices. It’s all part of the way the brain works, they say. So maybe Joan was sufferin’ from that and not some kind of divine calling. Who knows? The truth is, back then, they just didn’t have the tools to figure it out. And I reckon a lot of folks just thought she was one of those strange people who saw the world in a way nobody else could understand.
The Tragic End
Now, what’s even sadder is how poor Joan ended up. After all the battles and all the things she’d done, she was captured, tried for her so-called “crimes,” and burned at the stake. They called her a witch, a heretic, and all sorts of awful things. Some folks, they probably thought she was just a madwoman who’d gotten too caught up in her own visions. But to others, she was a hero, a martyr, someone who died for her beliefs. It’s a real sad story, if you ask me. Whether she was a saint, a schizophrenic, or somethin’ in between, she went through a lot, that’s for sure.
Was She A Saint Or A Sufferer?
In the end, it’s hard to say what Joan really was. Was she a messenger of God, like she claimed? Or was she just a poor woman with a mental illness that nobody understood? Maybe it’s a bit of both. Some folks think she was a saint, others say she was just someone who had a hard time with her mind. But either way, she’s remembered as someone who changed the course of history, whether it was by divine will or just because she was a brave young woman who fought for what she believed in.
So, what do you think? Was Joan of Arc a saint, a schizophrenic, or just a brave soul caught up in the winds of history? I reckon it’s up to each person to make up their mind. But one thing’s for sure: her story is one that won’t ever be forgotten.
Tags：[Joan of Arc, Schizophrenia, Mental Illness, Saints, History, Voices, Visions, Epilepsy, History of Joan of Arc, Saint Michael, Saint Catherine, Saint Margaret]
Original article by the Author:Kerwin,If you intend to republish this content, please attribute the source accordingly:https://www.creativesfunding.com/2282.html
相关推荐
-
Easy Comparison: Mayan Art and Aztec Art Differences
Alright, let’s talk about this Mayan art and Aztec art. You know, it’s like lookin’ at two different kinds of corn, both grow in the ground but look and taste a little different. Mayan Art, What’s That All About? Now, them Mayans, they were somethin’ else. They made all sorts of things, you know, outta stone, wood, clay… even that stucco stuff. They’d carve on it, paint on it, stick it on walls. Real fancy-like. They made jewelry too, pretty things outta jade and bone and shells. And the pictures…
-
Find Rare Toys Worth a Lot of Money: Simple Guide
Okay, so I’ve always been a bit of a pack rat, especially when it comes to toys. I just can’t seem to throw them away. I mean, they’re packed with memories, right? So the other day, I was digging through some old boxes in my attic, and it got me thinking: could any of these old toys actually be worth something? I started doing a little digging online – you know, just casually browsing, not really expecting to find much. I typed in stuff like “rare toys” and “valuable vintage…
-
Charlotte Davis: Profiles and Insights into Notable Figures
Well, now let me tell ya ‘bout this name, Charlotte Davis. Ain’t much to say ’bout her really, but I reckon if ya look real close, you’ll see all kinds of folks with that name, all walkin’ different paths. Some folks call themselves Charlotte Davis ’cause it’s just a name they got from their family, and some folks, they’s out there makin’ a name for themselves in all sorts of ways. Like, there’s this one gal who’s been all up in the politics. Yup, I heard she’s a Senior Legislative…
-
Exploring the Legacy of Conan in Frank Frazetta’s Iconic Artwork
Well, let me tell ya somethin’ about this Conan fella and this Frazetta guy who painted him up so fierce. Now, folks might not know right off, but this Frank Frazetta, he’s the fella who got folks real excited ’bout this barbarian Conan – ya know, big muscles, wild hair, swingin’ swords like he’s clearin’ out some thick weeds! Now, Frank, he ain’t no stranger to the big, bold artwork, ya know what I mean? He’s the one folks think of when they think ‘bout Conan. Back in the day,…
-
Discover the Beauty of Royalty Paintings: Timeless Artworks from British Royalty
Well, now, let me tell ya about them royal paintings. Them ones that hang up in big palaces and all that, where the fancy folks live. Now, I ain’t no art expert, but I do know a thing or two about them portraits, especially the ones that got somethin’ to do with them royals. They sure ain’t like the pictures you or I might hang up in our houses. Nope, these ones are big and mighty, showin’ all the glory and splendor of them kings and queens. You see, these…
-
Understanding The Red Book Medical: Key Insights and Uses in Healthcare
Well, let me tell ya, this “Red Book,” it’s somethin’ important. Now, ain’t nobody got time for fancy talk, so I’ll just give it to ya straight. This book right here, it’s a record book for all the stuff doctors do to your little one, like them shots. You know, the vaccines and all that. It’s mighty important to keep track of it all, ’cause you don’t want to forget which ones they got and when. So, when ya go to the doctor for the next round of shots, take…
-
Elegant Lamps: Find Your Perfect Style | Light Up Your Home with a Touch of Class
Okay, so, I’ve been wanting to spruce up my living room, and what better way to do that than with some elegant lighting? I decided to set up a lamp in the corner to make things a bit cozier. Here’s how I did it. First off, I picked a corner that was kind of dark and sad-looking. It was just begging for some light. Then I measured the space. I figured since it’s about 100 square feet, one floor lamp would do the trick. It’s a good rule of thumb…
-
Elephant with x eyes: What does it mean and where to see it?
Well, look here, let’s talk about this elephant with X eyes thing. I saw some pictures online, you know, on that phone thing my grandson showed me. The pictures were kinda weird, but interesting all the same. This fella, KAWS, he’s the one who draws these elephants with X’s for eyes. Now, I ain’t no artist, but it looks like them X’s mean the elephant’s… well, gone. Like in them cartoons when someone gets knocked out, they get X’s for eyes, right? It’s like this KAWS fella is saying the…
-
What is American Futurism All About? Get the Scoop on This Bold Vision!
Okay, so I’ve been diving deep into this “American Futurism” thing, and let me tell you, it’s been a wild ride. Started off just poking around, you know, curious about how folks back in the day pictured the future. Especially during that whole Cold War, Atomic Age deal. First, I hit up the usual spots online, just to get a feel for what’s out there. Found some interesting tidbits about how futurism was all wrapped up with government think tanks and what the economists were predicting. It got me thinking,…
-
I Ching Hexagram 18: Meaning, Interpretation, and Application
Well, let me tell ya ’bout this 18 i ching thing. I ain’t no scholar, mind you, just an old woman who’s seen a thing or two. But I heard folks talkin’ ’bout it, and I reckon I can piece together what it all means, ya know, in my own way. This 18 i ching, they call it “Corruption” or “Work on What Has Been Spoiled.” Sounds about right, doesn’t it? Life’s like that sometimes. Things fall apart, get messed up. Like that old barn we had, roof leakin’, wood…